top of page

Composition
Composer(s)
Artist
Year Released
Chart Appearance
Artist
Year Released
Chart Appearance
My Prerogative
Bobby Brown, Aaron Hall & Teddy Riley
1988
1 (Hot 100)
2004
N/A (Hot 100)


If you live in a house that’s carpeted, then you understand that the home builders meticulously measured the spaces before cutting the carpets so that, once laid, it fit perfectly into your particular home. If you move out of that first home and into another, you can’t pull the carpeting up from the first and just put it down in the second because that shit won’t fit right. That’s what the experts call custom fitting. “My Prerogative” is a custom-fitted song that only Bobby Brown could perform. If someone else tries to rip it up and use it in their own home, it will look ill-fitted and raggedy. I’m looking at you, Britney.
Even Bobby must have looked up from his mirrored coffee table and laughed when he heard that Britney Spears wanted to cover his signature song, but after drinking and smoking away every little cent he made, he was lucid enough to recognize a potential financial windfall when he saw it. So, sign off he did on “My Prerogative”, his baby, the non-cocaine-based substance that defines his musical career. As jam packed with hits as 1988’s “Don’t Be Cruel” was, “My Prerogative” remains Bobby’s sole #1 on the U.S. Hot 100, a song that is an amalgamation of everything Brown stood for: being rich, single, ready to mingle and unconcerned about being doused with Haterade. The song was also the funkiest track on the charts and it fit Bobby to a T as it allowed him to show off the singing and limber dance moves that moved Whitney to pin the “King of R&B” moniker on him. It’s also the song that put Teddy Riley on the pop world map, an accolade that Riley built upon. (Bobby’s fortunes turned downward pretty quickly and that’s why he needed someone of Spears’ stature to cover his music.)


The minute Britney Spears stood behind the mike to sing Brown’s song, she never really stood a chance. The Indian-inspired sitar and tambura playing on her version is a nice touch, but they also seem really out of place here. “My Prerogative” is about being defiant and unapologetic while sending all the haters to hell. And the song should be sung that way. I don’t know, but Britney’s singing doesn’t come across as aggressive or forceful at all. Surprisingly, it barely goes above a nasal-y whisper, even on the chorus. I’m not sure why she didn’t let loose and attack the song with robust and soaring high notes. Her version of the song didn’t even crack the Hot 100. I just don’t get it.
Just kidding. Spears’ version of “My Prerogative” completely stinks from start to finish, leaving her fans shaking their heads and lamenting, “oops, she did it again.”



“My Prerogative” Grade Report
Bobby Brown
Grade: A
Britney Spears
Grade: D-
Comments
Share Your ThoughtsBe the first to write a comment.
bottom of page
.png)
